n8n vs Make vs Zapier: 1K to 100K Leads
n8n vs Make vs Zapier is a billing question as much as a workflow question. My identical AI lead classifier used one n8n execution, three Make credits, or one to two Zapier tasks per lead. The platforms sell execution, credit and task tiers, not packages of leads. That changes the monthly bill.
I build LLM pipelines in Python and am new to no-code platforms. I tested what was charged and what happened when things failed.
Quick answer from the tests:
|
Tool |
Units per lead |
Parallel 20-lead burst |
401 failure |
Biggest gotcha |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
n8n self-hosted |
1 execution |
15/20; 20/20 with retries |
Not tested |
Test and live URLs differ |
|
Make |
3 credits |
20/20 |
Scenario switched off |
Router needs fallback |
|
Zapier |
1 spam or 2 hot tasks |
20/20 |
Alert, manual replay |
9 configured steps |
How I tested
On each platform: webhook, Groq openai/gpt-oss-120b, JSON lead classification (hot, warm or spam), then Slack #hot-leads for hot leads or a leads table otherwise. I also trimmed the company field. All tests came from one Windows machine. n8n ran in Docker, Make on Free (EU1), Zapier on its 14-day Professional trial.
$body = @{
name = 'Ali Test'
email = 'ali@example.com'
company = ' TechBoss AI '
message = 'We need an AI chatbot for our business. Budget is $5000.'
} | ConvertTo-Json
Invoke-RestMethod -Uri 'WEBHOOK_URL' -Method Post -Body $body -ContentType 'application/json'curl.exe mangled JSON quotes. Double-quoted PowerShell strings swallowed $5000, so Zapier’s Slack output said Budget. Single quotes fixed it.
n8n vs Make vs Zapier cost per lead
| Platform | Hot | Not hot | Measured billing |
| n8n self-hosted | 1 execution | 1 execution | No per-run platform fee; server costs extra |
| Make | 3 credits | 3 credits | Webhook, HTTP and Slack/store; Router free |
| Zapier | 2 tasks | 1 task | HTTP plus Slack for hot; HTTP only for spam |
Zapier’s counter moved from 3 to 33 after ten hot and ten spam leads. Make Free has 1,000 credits and two active scenarios, enough for 333 complete leads on this workflow. Zapier Free has two-step Zaps and no webhook access, so it cannot run this workflow (check current plan terms).
Monthly cost at 1K, 10K, 50K and 100K leads
The screenshots show these monthly billing anchors, without annual discounts:
| Tool | Confirmed monthly selections |
| n8n Cloud | Starter 2.5K executions = $24; Pro 10K = $60; Business self-hosted 40K = $960 |
| Make Core | 10K credits = $10.59; 20K = $18.82; 40K = $34.12; 80K = $64.71 |
| Zapier Professional | 750 tasks = $29.99; 2K = $73.50; 10K = $193.50 |
First, multiply the observed units per lead. For Zapier, the middle case assumes 50% hot leads.
| Leads/month | n8n executions | Make credits | Zapier all Spam | Zapier 50% hot | Zapier all Hot |
| 1,000 | 1,000 | 3,000 | 1,000 tasks | 1,500 tasks | 2,000 tasks |
| 10,000 | 10,000 | 30,000 | 10,000 tasks | 15,000 tasks | 20,000 tasks |
| 50,000 | 50,000 | 150,000 | 50,000 tasks | 75,000 | 100,000 tasks |
| 100,000 | 100,000 | 300,000 | 100,000 tasks | 150,000 | 200,000 tasks |
Now select a sufficient monthly-billed plan, even when it leaves unused units.
| Leads/month | n8n Cloud | Make Core | Zapier Professional | n8n self-hosted |
| 1,000 | $24, Starter 2.5K executions | $10.59, 10K credits | $73.50, 2K tasks covers all three hot-share cases | Small VPS about $4 to $7 [estimated] |
| 10,000 | $60, Pro 10K executions | $34.12, 40K credits; | All spam: $193.50, 10K tasks; 50% hot and all hot: [check live price] | Vary based on selected service |
| 50,000 | custom | $113.85, 150K credits | custom | Vary based on selected service |
| 100,000 | custom | custom | custom | Vary based on selected service |
The $73.50 Zapier option is a confirmed sufficient 2K tier, not proof there is no cheaper tier for 1,000 or 1,500 tasks. Its 750-task tier is $29.99 but cannot cover 1,000 leads even when all are spam. Make’s 30K-credit requirement can use the pictured 40K tier. A calculated alternative is $18.82 for 20K plus 10K extra credits at Make’s documented 25% premium: $30.58. It is not a 30K subscription quote.

1K: Make is the cheapest-priced managed option shown, at $10.59. 10K: Make is lowest among the priced managed options, at $34.12 for a fixed tier or $30.58 with the modeled extra-credit purchase. 50K: Make’s $113.85 is documented, but the other high-volume tiers are unknown. 100K: There is no defensible platform-wide price winner yet.

An alternative 100K Make budget model is $256.16: $113.85 for 150K credits plus another 150K bought at Make’s documented 25% extra-credit premium. This is calculated, not a confirmed 300K-tier quote; the 300K Core tier may be cheaper. n8n’s pictured $960 Business plan covers 40K executions and is self-hosted only, so it is not a 50K Cloud plan.
Projection, not a load test. These figures assume no retries, exclude the same Groq API cost on each platform, and do not establish server throughput, taxes, storage or operational cost. Annual-billing discounts are deliberately excluded.
What happens when a run fails
n8n: Five of twenty parallel leads failed with Groq’s too many requests. None reached Slack or the table. After enabling Retry On Fail (three tries, 2,000 ms), the repeated burst finished 20/20. Runs took about 1 to 2 seconds; Docker used about 500 MiB idle and 620 MiB peak. I did not test n8n with a 401.

Make: Sequential and parallel 20-lead batches each completed 20/20; parallel Slack order changed. A deliberately wrong key billed two credits, kept the lead in Incomplete executions when enabled, and disabled the scenario with Unauthorized. After a fix and reactivation, the retry ran 2 operations and resolved the lead, but did not appear as a billed event in Credit Usage (total stayed at 140). Its retry charge is unconfirmed.
Zapier: Its parallel batch completed 20/20 (ten hot, ten spam), with scrambled Slack order. A bad key cost zero tasks for the failed step. The Zap stayed active, and an Invalid API Key email arrived within a minute. I replayed manually; success cost two tasks. I did not test automatic replay.

Make and Zapier showed no Groq limits during these tests; that does not establish better 429 handling.
Where each tool made me work
n8n: Test and production webhook URLs differ. Header Auth was on by default, and Slack needed one extra permission. Insert row did not forward lead fields, so I used $('Webhook'). Docker required a volume for persistence.
Make: I needed a sample webhook before mapping fields, a structured data store, and a Router fallback to keep hot leads out of the table. trim() avoided another module, but Groq JSON was raw text. An empty payload still consumed credits. Signup took three minutes; Maia dominated the dashboard, module search surfaced an unrelated Make, and the Map toggle and JSON escaping caused friction.
Zapier: It detected JSON fields automatically and used one test/live webhook URL, returning success before processing finished. Nine configured steps included two Formatters and rules on both Paths branches. Seven steps ran on a hot lead. I built Table columns manually, and the paid features stop when the trial ends.
What I did not test
I did not measure n8n or Zapier build time, export n8n JSON, confirm Make’s retry billing, or actually run 1K, 10K, 50K or 100K leads. I did not test sustained throughput, VPS sizing, storage limits, n8n 401 recovery, or Make/Zapier 429 recovery. The monthly volume figures are projections.
Which one to pick
Pick n8n self-hosted if Docker is comfortable and one execution per lead suits you; retries took my burst from 15/20 to 20/20. Skip it if you cannot manage storage, retries and hosting.
Pick Make if three predictable credits per lead and visual routing suit you; both 20-lead batches succeeded. Skip it if you cannot monitor a scenario that a 401 may deactivate.
Pick Zapier if the tested 401 email and manual replay are valuable; it billed one task for spam and two for hot. Skip it if that split or paid-feature dependence breaks your budget.
My choice: n8n when I can operate the host, Make for a lower-cost managed workflow at verified small volumes, Zapier when alerting and replay matter more than the bill.
Which is cheapest at 10,000 leads?
Make Core is the cheapest managed option at 10,000 leads per month, costing $34.12.
Can this run on free plans?
Make Free covers 333 complete leads monthly. n8n was self-hosted. Zapier Free cannot run this webhook-based, multi-step workflow.
What happens when Groq rate-limits a run?
Only n8n hit a Groq rate limit in my tests: five of twenty failed. Three retries with a 2,000 ms wait recovered the repeated burst.
Need help architecting an AI automation stack?
Build a production-ready automation agent pipeline that protects deliverability, minimizes latency, and scales cleanly without technical debt.
Contact Me →Useful Links:
n8n pricing | Zapier pricing | Make.com pricing | n8n-workflow-json
